Plea To Stop USDA Poultry Inspection Change

Nearly 150,000 petitions were delivered and served causing USDA to extend its comment period.

Published on: May 3, 2012

Consumer watchdogs, concerned citizens and federal food inspectors represented by the American Federation of Government Employees has delivered nearly 150,000 petitions to the USDA opposing proposed changes to the poultry inspections process that will impact the health and safety of the American public.

USDA official Sally Liska accepted the petitions on behalf of USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack. The petitions, which were circulated by AFGE and other groups, denounce a regulation proposed by Agriculture's Food Safety and Inspection Service that would partially privatize the poultry inspections process and drastically increase the number of birds federal inspectors must examine.

Agricultural engineer from the USDAs Agricultural Research Service works on developing an automatic scanning system for inspecting chicken carcasses. Cameras, along with near-infrared and visible light scans will be positioned along the inspection line and linked to a computer, which will identify defects and disease and direct the imperfect chickens to a separate production line. ARS photo by Keith Weller
Agricultural engineer from the USDA's Agricultural Research Service works on developing an automatic scanning system for inspecting chicken carcasses. Cameras, along with near-infrared and visible light scans will be positioned along the inspection line and linked to a computer, which will identify defects and disease and direct the imperfect chickens to a separate production line. ARS photo by Keith Weller

"Budget cuts are driving the USDA to take this drastic step, which would reduce our highly trained teams of federal food safety inspectors to a skeleton crew who would have to review three birds every second – a humanly impossible task," says AFGE National President John Gage. "This is a recipe that appears to be putting diseased chickens right on our kitchen tables, and we are urging the USDA to reconsider this foolish and dangerous proposal."

The day after ABC World News broadcast a story on the controversial proposal, FSIS announced it would extend the comment period on the proposed rule by an additional 30 days. The original deadline was April 26; nearly 600 comments have been submitted on the rule so far.

The USDA proposal would extend nationwide a pilot project that has allowed some poultry companies to inspect their own chickens. But an analysis released last month by the nonprofit Food & Water Watch, which partnered with AFGE on the petition drive, revealed that large numbers of defects are routinely being missed when inspection tasks are performed by company employees instead of USDA inspectors.

In addition, FSIS data obtained by AFGE under the Freedom of Information Act revealed that company inspectors operating under the pilot project remove far fewer diseased birds than federal inspectors operating under the traditional process. At one company, Pilgrim's Pride, the condemnation rate for diseased birds is twice as high at the traditional plant as compared to the privatized plant.