HSUS Going After King Amendment in Farm Bill

Group says farm bill amendment from Rep. Steve King threatens animals; Rep. King says it prevents agriculture's demise

Published on: Aug 6, 2013

The Humane Society of the United States in recent weeks has been turning up the heat on Congress to throw out a state's rights amendment offered by Rep. Steve King, R-Iowa, in the 2013 Farm Bill.

The King amendment, also known as the Protect Interstate Commerce Act amendment, would prevent states from enacting laws that place conditions on how agricultural goods are raised or grown within the state's borders for sale in other states.

The PICA amendment puts significant pressure on standing laws in California, for example, which require that all egg-laying hens be housed in larger cages by 2015.  The state's laws further require that all eggs sold in the state must be produced by farms that adhere to California's cage standards.

Group says amendment from Rep. Steve King, R-Iowa, threatens animals; Rep. King says it prevents agricultures demise
Group says amendment from Rep. Steve King, R-Iowa, threatens animals; Rep. King says it prevents agriculture's demise

King explained that in California's case, the impact of their large market would "compel producers in other states to invest billions to meet the California standard of 'means of production,'" thereby harming ag trade.

In an op-ed for the National Cattlemen's Beef Association, King further explained that laws such as California's create new federal animal welfare standards by imposing an unconstitutional trade barrier.

"If this law is allowed to stand, there is nothing preventing other states from imposing similar standards, which could further restrict producers in other states," King said.

King also argued that his farm bill amendment would "shut down the Humane Society of the United States, PETA and other radical organizations from creating a network of restrictive state laws that will slowly push agriculture production towards the demise."

But HSUS CEO Wayne Pacelle fired back with his own take on the regulations, calling King "one of the most radical Members of Congress" in an August 2 blog post.


Pacelle compared King's amendment to "legislative kudzu, so invasive and dangerous it could crowd out hundreds of state and local laws setting appropriate standards for agriculture."

Further, he noted that the amendment would prevent states' rights to impose "reasonable standards" on agriculture to protect animals, workers, the environment and consumers.

A group of lawmakers are also joining in to back HSUS' position, noting in a letter to House Ag Committee Ranking Member Collin Peterson, dated Aug. 2, that the amendment could repeal laws that cover food safety and environmental protection, not just farm animals.

"For example, labeling and other rules for products and ingredients such as artificial sweeteners, maple syrup, milk fat, farm-raised fish, tobacco, and additives in alcohol could be swept away," the group said.

Additionally, they claimed that it could present a hurdle to cross in the grand scheme of farm bill negotiations.

"The King amendment represents an additional layer of serious controversy on already controversial legislation. As you work with colleagues to develop a final Farm Bill package for consideration by the House and to find sufficient votes to pass it, we strongly urge you to do all you can to keep out the King amendment and any provision like it," they said.

The amendment has already seen significant debate during House markup of the farm bill, though it passed on a voice vote.

Add Comment
  1. dissertation writing help of http://www.dissertation-writers.net/dissertation-w says:

    I loved the author's notes on judgments about the business! Author, keep up the good work)

  2. The ad has to be located right in the middle of the page so it could be viewed more than once and people interested could actually proceed to buy the car once they go through the details.

    • You must be mentioned here that has something for everyone. I hope you will get some answers, cannot promise if you will.

    • http://www.orangeville-realestateagents.com of http://www.orangeville-realestateagents.com says:

      Below is just such a compilation of suggestions that will help anyone interested in a pro when it comes to buying or selling commercial real estate. Regardless of whether you are buying or selling the property, negotiate! Make

  3. This bill certainly needs editing, because it not finish! It is necessary to amend!

    • http://www.sportsucht.com of http://www.sportsucht.com says:

      Purchasing commercial real estate is much from obtaining a home. The following tips will greatly assist you in making the best commercial real estate purchases. Use your digital camera to document the conditions.

  4. Amendments to the Farm Bill was expected, since in recent years in this industry there is a strong ekonomichesky recession and the government should encourage such as this situation. Therefore, I'm definitely for this bill.

    • http://www.kerryfinnrealestate.com of http://www.kerryfinnrealestate.com says:

      Select your agent wisely when you want to sell or buy a home. You should make sure the agent is experienced if you wan to buy or sell any real estate. An experienced real estate agent will help ensure that you home is sold quickly and the best price.

    • http://www.personalfinanceloans.org of http://www.personalfinanceloans.org says:

      Essentially, when it involves bad credit charge cards and financial loans, you will need to go 1 of 2 ways. You will get secured financial loans or charge cards, which indicates you set up collateral regarding loans as well as endow advancing money in the placement of charge cards.

      • sportscurrentevents of sportscurrentevents says:

        When there is a large sporting event happening, maybe it is time for that Olympics or possibly it's the actual Super Dish, you may use those things inside your marketing, particularly if people understand you're the sports enthusiast or you've sports fans inside your target marketplace.

  5. infomercial production says:

    The PICA variation puts significant pressure on standing rules in Florida, for example, which need that all egg-laying birds be located in larger crates by 2015. The region's rules further need that all egg sold in the state must be produced by plants that adhere to California's crate requirements. http://www.infomercialproduction.net/infomercial-advertising-and-marketing-services/infomercial-production-service/

  6. Music instruction refers to any lesson involving music and instruments to create music. It can be part of a school's course load or as a special class for students who are musically inclined. Examples include music instruction on voice, piano, guitar, drums, and flute, among a great many others.

  7. Your guide's job is not to necessarily keep your from making mistakes, getting into trouble or ever having any difficult or dangerous or even disappointing experiences. All of this is the very fiber that makes up the fabric of your life.

  8. TomT says:

    Can you please tell us more about this issue? California is a state that gets rain almost exclusively in the winter for most of the state. It is also a state with a lot of mountainous terrain. This would necessitate making a good grazing plan, would it not? Is there difficulty in preparing a good grazing plan? Are you not getting support from those requiring it? Are the rules regarding this unreasonable? Your property management has a chance of your property washing onto your neighbors or degrading watersheds. Are you actually thinking about these issues?

  9. TomT says:

    .....so.... republicans don't really believe in states rights, do they? It seems to me that if California wants to regulate their food products, they should be able to do so. It is their state right to do so, no matter what the corporate conglomerates want.

  10. s says:

    In a highly restricted state like california we need protection from our local government to compete with other states. Needing to file a grazing plan on private property in some areas is just one of many things we are forced to do.

    • Jackson of http://dentalvideo.net says:

      Very nice and detailed information you have provided me with the best information.

    • weddingflowerideas of http://www.weddingflowerideas.org says:

      Using flowers will then add color, fragrance as well as joy in order to every marriage ceremony. Flowers happen to be used through the years in several ceremonies, for example births, partnerships and fatalities. They enhance different feelings at each and every occasion.

  11. Emily says:

    What has happened? Where is common sense, compassion, and reason? What insanity is this King Amendment, PICA? Why did this pass on a voice vote? This amendment MUST be kept out of the Farm Bill. What an atrocity to animals, farm workers, food safety and citizenry when protections are stripped away for profit! The character of a man is determined by how he treats an animal. To allow this to pass is an abomination against nature and men's souls.

Free Reports