Beef Producers Face Problems With Sexing Semen

Beef producers using sex-sorted semen may find glitch during AI.

Published on: Dec 10, 2013

Gender-sorted semen has been used to successfully produce calves since 1992. Since then, the technology has evolved and become commercially available. Until recently, dairy producers mostly used gender-sorted semen, or semen used to select the gender of the calf. Now, it has found a place in the beef industry. At about 150 to 200% of the cost of conventional semen, it takes a certain management strategy to make it work.

Jordan Thomas, University of Missouri graduate student, is finding that pregnancy rates with timed AI does not work well with sex-sorted semen. "Part of it has to do with how long the sperm will retain fertility in the female reproductive tract," Thomas says. "Additionally, in a timed AI situation, you might only have half of the cows show heat by the time of AI."

Jordan Thomas, MU graduate student and the MU animal science department recently conducted a study looking at a split-timed method, using an Estrotect heat detection aid. Using timed AI, cows that expressed estrus by the time of AI were inseminated then. The ones that didnt express estrus were inseminated 20 hours after the GnRH administration, which resulted in a significant increase in pregnancy rates.
Jordan Thomas, MU graduate student and the MU animal science department recently conducted a study looking at a split-timed method, using an Estrotect heat detection aid. Using timed AI, cows that expressed estrus by the time of AI were inseminated then. The ones that didn't express estrus were inseminated 20 hours after the GnRH administration, which resulted in a significant increase in pregnancy rates.

Gonadotropin-releasing hormone, or GnRH, is used in timed AI protocols for this reason. "That product is used specifically because we're trying to get a tighter window of ovulation times and shorten what would have been a longer period of heat detection," Thomas says. "But when using sex-sorted semen, time breeding non-estrous females off GnRH administration is less effective."

Split-timed AI study
Thomas and the MU animal science department recently conducted a study looking at a split-timed method, using an Estrotect heat detection aid, a patch with gray-colored coating that scratches off when the cow is mounted by another to detect estrus. Using timed AI, cows that expressed estrus by the time of AI were inseminated then. The ones that didn't express estrus were inseminated 20 hours after the GnRH administration. "It was actually a pretty dramatic increase that we noted by doing that," Thomas says. "And it's an easy management strategy. Everything comes through that first day regardless of what their patch looks like. It's just a matter of sorting out those gray ones – that didn't express estrus."

The trial compared three treatment groups: one with conventional semen and timed AI, which had a pregnancy rate of 56%. Another group, with sex-sorted semen and timed AI had a 26% pregnancy rate. "That sort of illustrates the challenge of using sex-sorted semen in straight timed AI," Thomas notes. They then used the split-timed approach with sex-sorted semen. "By using the split-timed approach we actually achieved a 13% [average] increase to that timed AI approach, so we bumped that up to 39% overall. And that bump really came from those non-estrous females that were held over."

The question of profitability
With its cost, Thomas says the big question is how and when gender-sorted semen will be profitable to use. Its profitability currently depends on the individual operation and how the rancher markets a particular gender. "In addition to the higher semen cost, there is obviously a cost associated with somewhat lower pregnancy rates when using sex-sorted semen. There has to be a return for that to make sense," Thomas notes. "I think the places where it's going to make sense to use sex-sorted semen the quickest is in operations that market elite bulls or heifers. If there's a big payoff, you can stomach a slightly higher cost a little better."

Although it will take some math to tell how profitable it is for specific situations, Thomas says there is a lot of potential for gender-sorted semen. "There is definitely reason to be encouraged about all this," he says. "I think we are to the point now that we can use sex-sorted semen on beef cows and we can get pretty good pregnancy rates. I think it's just a matter of whether it can work financially."

To view how one Missouri beef producer uses semen in his operation click here.